---

April 13, 2010 04:19 PM

David said:

The Third Rule
The film is great. Whoever and wherever they found the actor, Fabian Hogarth, ha ha ha, he is quite good. He should try and make a go at acting... You gotta see it.

---

April 13, 2010 06:20 PM

Brad said:

The Third Rule
Wow, this film has great potential at Tribeca! It's hilarious! Good luck!

---

April 13, 2010 06:22 PM

Kenan said:

The Third Rule
Aundre, Congratulations, especially for the part about the mongoose. I hope this does really well at the festival.

---

April 13, 2010 06:33 PM

Lauren said:

Third rule
omg i love these guys.

---

April 15, 2010 12:06 PM

Rita said:

The Third Rule
This film is seriously funny! I love these actors too. Remember the mongoose!

---

April 16, 2010 05:21 PM

erin said:

The Third Rule Original
Its unfortunate that things like this happen. The Third Rule was originally created by a few people in 2009, with "Fabian Hogarth". "Fabian Hogarth" agreed to make this movie because of the original cast.It was filmed and recorded with other actors in 2009. Aundre Johnson, lied to, and manipulated the original cast, creators, writers to get close to Fabian Hogarth, as one of the cast members was close friends with "fabian". I would love to hear what Aundre Johnson has to say about how this movie was created, in writing, publicly. As there are many witnesses that know how The Third Rule was originally created.

---

April 16, 2010 05:52 PM

J said:

wow
Aundre left the original cast up on IMDB until today, probably to try and prevent something like this.I'm shocked Aundre, as a "friend of bill" that you would be so slimy. And what happened to Ian Somerhalders cut from the original Third Rule?

---

April 16, 2010 07:02 PM

Not to worry said:

Third rule
To the original people involved in The Third Rule. The WGA, SAG, and directors guild have your back. You will be fully protected.

---

April 17, 2010 01:48 AM

Sameer Bhavnani said:

I know this will be good!
I first saw some films from Aundre his school submitted some to my festival, and they were ALL awesome, it was tough to pick just one to put in the festival. If he directed this, and wrote this, i know it'll be good, can't wait to see it.

---

April 17, 2010 02:00 AM

Andrew said:

Cannot wait to see this
As a writer who has collaborated with Aundre Johnson in the past, and a fan of his earlier short films, I am very excited about seeing The Third Rule.

---

April 17, 2010 02:03 AM

Dongo said:

Third Rule
Third Rule rules! Hahaha! Hilarious. Obvious candidate for a feature. Way to go!

---

April 17, 2010 03:10 PM

Charlie Burr said:

Excited for The Third Rule
I've seen all of Aundre's shorts and if The Third Rule is like the others then this will be great! Congrats Aundre!

---

April 18, 2010 07:49 PM

Kenneth Dorf said:

Andre
I have known Andre for about 10 years. Worked with him at the Palm Springs Short Film Ferstival. As Manager of the Market Place I had the privledge to see all of Posh Films and was glad when Andre won for best picture a few years ago. Good luck on this latest fun great film Ken

---

April 19, 2010 11:04 AM

Tim Kern said:

Can't Wait
I've seen 4 1/2 and Crisis '76 and those were excellent and I've heard so much about The Third Rule. Can't wait to watch it this Friday. congrats, Aundre.

---

April 19, 2010 02:35 PM

David said:

Third Rule.
Wow! What a great vid at the start! Who is that handsome guy singing? All in all, a work of staggering genius.

---

April 19, 2010 06:00 PM

Ron J. said:

Third Rule
Great job, Aundre. Can't wait to see it on Friday!!!!!

---

April 19, 2010 06:51 PM

Tim said:

Third Rule
Great to see so many positive things being posted. I had a blast composing the music for The Third Rule, and I'm looking forward to seeing it all on the big screen Friday night. Hope to meet a bunch of Third Rule fans there, too! Congrats, Aundre -- see you in NYC!

---

April 19, 2010 09:49 PM

Mike said:

Good stuff
I've been lucky enough to see a ripped copy of this film on the internet, and its great!!!

---

April 20, 2010 07:03 PM

DB said:

Erin and J response
Erin & J & whomever else – I thought that I should respond to your notes posted here. I can appreciate your disappointment with Aundre’s finished film, but you should try and keep that disappointment in check. I’ve been a friend and fan of Aundre’s work for many years. When he showed me a rough cut of the project, my only critical comment was that some of the casting was a little weak. Apparently, that comment and others like it caused him and his associate, Mr. Hogarth, to finish the film with some revisions including re-casting. This happens while making films. I think most actors at some time or another are recast and although it can be painful, it is part of the process. Filmmakers have to have the ability to finish their films in the manner they envision. Sometimes that vision isn’t shared by everyone, but it is the process. As for your comments about Aundre lying to “everyone” to get to Fabian Hogarth – Fabian and Aundre have known each other for over 10 years. The project was their idea and everyone associated was invited to participate in Aundre’s film by their mutual decisions – just as the final film is a product of their mutual decisions. Your misguided anger and point of view is an example of why the changes were made. I hope that my comments don’t come across as too harsh. I wish you the best of luck as you move forward on your future projects.

---

April 20, 2010 07:20 PM

J-WOW said:

HUH.
I really want to watch this, among the other shorts, but it seems there is some real animosity from everyone involved. And who is Fabian Hogarth? I hate it when people freak out over movies that end up not being good. So, I hope this is good!

---

April 21, 2010 06:05 AM

KC said:

Script Supervisor
I have a side splitting time on the film. Had a great Director in Mr. Johnson and the UPM was a dear. Let's expand the film, it's too funny not to. All my best in the festival.

---

April 21, 2010 08:29 AM

joey feldman said:

see this.
this is a great little movie that aundre has whipped up-not only boosts a bunch of surprises in its short run time, but serves up some great laughs. J-WOW-if u dont know fabian hogarth, then youve been living under a rock- this is something to freak out about

---

April 21, 2010 12:24 PM

redrugger said:

amazing
Aundre Johnson hits the mark in this short. It left you wanting more and more comedy and hopefully a full feature is made. If there is one short that you get to see at Tribeca this year, make sure its The Third Rule.

---

April 21, 2010 01:16 PM

Noelle Fanaris said:

Congratulations Aundre!

---

April 21, 2010 01:17 PM

Bob Phillips said:

CONGRATS AUNDRE!
I've been hearing about this project for quite a while and about your considerable talent as a filmmaker. I wish you the best in the festival and in your career. I look forward to seeing the film.

---

April 21, 2010 01:21 PM

Barbara said:

I can't wait to see Aundre Johnson's new short this week. I've heard nothing but great things and heard its absolutely hilarious.

---

April 21, 2010 01:32 PM

Meghan said:

The behind the scenes clips are great. Looking forward to seeing it at the festival. Jason Biggs is so funny.

---

April 21, 2010 01:34 PM

Heywood said:

Aweaome, Aundre!
Congrats and break a leg!

---

April 21, 2010 01:38 PM

Michael said:

I LOVE THIS FILM! Fantastic that it's screening at TRIBECA! I hope this leads to it becoming a feature. All my best, Andre, you're a great filmmaker.

---

April 21, 2010 01:41 PM

Nathan said:

Good Luck!
Great job on the film - amazing cast! Looking forward to it being in the festival!

---

April 21, 2010 01:57 PM

Cotty Chubb said:

Don't Forget Me (when you hit the big time)
'Cause I knew you when! Congratulations, Aundre. It's a long way from where you started. I wish I could be there with you when it screens. Cotty

---

April 21, 2010 01:59 PM

Tom said:

I've seen some of Aundre's other work and I honestly cannot wait for this one. All the best!

---

April 21, 2010 02:10 PM

Leilani said:

Good Luck
CONGRATS AUNDRE! This short is hilarious..Can't wait to see more

---

April 21, 2010 02:10 PM

Jbombs said:

uh oh
This movie looks awesome..and Jason Biggs is super adorbs so why wouldn't anyone wanna see this..def going :)

---

April 21, 2010 02:11 PM

Hillary said:

I can't wait!
This looks amazing and I can't WAITTTT to see it!

---

April 21, 2010 02:13 PM

poppy said:

great short!
really happy to see more of Jason Biggs ;)

---

April 21, 2010 02:13 PM

Jbombs said:

uh oh
This movie looks awesome..and Jason Biggs is super adorbs so why wouldn't anyone wanna see this..def going :)

---

April 21, 2010 02:15 PM

Casey said:

Looks so rad
This is going to be EPIC! I wanna see it

---

April 21, 2010 02:20 PM

whitey said:

Awesome job Aundre, funnier than I thought, definitely deserves to be a winner - luck at the festival.

---

April 21, 2010 03:34 PM

Adam Moos said:

Just Win Baby!
Hey Aundre, Great job on the film and getting into Tribeca! Good luck at the Festival!

---

April 21, 2010 03:38 PM

Suzy White said:

Congratulations Aundre -- best of luck to you at the festival. Should do well. We support you!!

---

April 21, 2010 05:21 PM

Jack Cloud said:

EXCITING!!
Congratulations Aundre -- best of luck to you at the festival. You've made a really terrific short! I hope it goes all the way. You've worked very hard for this. Good Luck!

---

April 21, 2010 05:45 PM

Debbie colton said:

Aundre Johnson
aundre Johnson

---

April 21, 2010 05:46 PM

Debbie Colton said:

Aundre Johnson
Cngratulations Aundre!!! I'm so happy for you - Break a leg! We'll be watching!

---

April 21, 2010 05:47 PM

Debbie Colton said:

Aundre Johnson
Cngratulations Aundre!!! I'm so happy for you - Break a leg! We'll be watching!

---

April 21, 2010 06:30 PM

Tom Walls said:

The Third Rule
Good for you Aundre you deserve it. Best of luck.

---

April 21, 2010 10:03 PM

Sean Humphries said:

Proving the Haters wrong
The Third Rule is a hilarious and original film. Previously, it was hampered by poor performances. Now, however, with fresh, talented PROFESSIONAL actors the film has the life it deserves. I've worked with Aundré Johnson on several projects and found him insightful, gifted and professional. Sore losers - the movie proves you're misguided. Talent and resilience persevere. Thanx Aundré.

---

April 22, 2010 07:39 AM

J said:

And poor performance comes from POOR DIRECTION!

---

April 22, 2010 08:53 AM

Mike said:

I've seen some of Aundre Johnson's other shorts and they are all great. The Third Rule looks hilarious and the actors both look very funny. Check out the behind the scenes takes on youtube, gives you a great feel for the comedic pace of a really good movie.

---

April 22, 2010 08:55 AM

Sam said:

I saw the Behind The Scenes cuts on youtube, they are great. The two actors together are really funny, and it seems like they have a great atmosphere to work in for director Aundre Johnson.

---

April 22, 2010 08:59 AM

jack white said:

Aundre Johnson
Congrats on the festival Aundre. Good luck! You're gonna do great.

---

April 22, 2010 09:02 AM

nick said:

Just checked out the Behind The Scenes takes on facebook, the movie looks hilarious. I'll definitely be seeing this film this weekend.

---

April 22, 2010 09:05 AM

james olsen said:

Aundre Johnson's short films are really funny. I can't wait for this one. I have my tickets for the festival already and its going to be great.

---

April 22, 2010 09:06 AM

T said:

I worked on this film and laughed through the entire shooting process. Good luck Aundre!

---

April 22, 2010 09:12 AM

Mike said:

I haven't been this excited for a Jason Biggs vehicle since Loser!

---

April 22, 2010 09:31 AM

Madmagnum said:

Congrats!
I cant wait to see this. I hear its so funny. keep up the good work and don't let anyone keep you down.

---

April 22, 2010 10:09 AM

Carolyn Pfeiffer said:

Aundre Johnson
Dear Aundre, I am so glad you have been acknowledged by Tribeca. You are a gifted young filmmaker with a lot of fans. Keep up the good work and I look forward to seeing THE THIRD RULE. Cheers, Carolyn

---

April 22, 2010 10:40 AM

Peter Chelsom said:

Hopkins
I can't wait to see this. A Knight in your short film. WTF! All my best, Peter Chelsom.

---

April 22, 2010 11:35 AM

Dudley said:

Congrats
I look forward to seeing the film. I've only heard great things about it. Congratulations Aundre!

---

April 22, 2010 11:41 AM

Chris said:

Cannot wait to see this movie! It is going to be great. Aundre has made some great stuff in the past and from what I've seen this is going to be just as good if not better. Congrats Aundre!

---

April 22, 2010 04:28 PM

Ben Parker said:

Congratulations!
Best of luck! The Third Rule should be expanded into a feature. It's smart and funny. Keep doing what you do, Aundre.

---

April 22, 2010 05:59 PM

Cathleen said:

I can't wait to see this movie, it looks hysterical, good job!

---

April 22, 2010 06:50 PM

Christine said:

Congratulations!
So exciting - best of luck to you Aundre! Can't wait to see it!

---

April 22, 2010 09:03 PM

Michael said:

I had a great time working on this short film. All three stars attached were professional and very down to earth. I would love to work along side every one again and I really hope that it happens in the near future. I wish the best for this short.

---

April 23, 2010 03:05 AM

Massimo said:

GO FOR IT
An amazing ensemble of talents both in front and behind the camera confirming that what Aundre Johnson have shown in the past was just the tip of his huge iceberg of great filmaking. All the best! DO NOT MISS IT!

---

April 23, 2010 05:59 AM

KC Calloway said:

Script Supervisor
As the Script Supervisor of The Third Rule I was delighted to work with the cast and crew of this sidespliting short. It took a great deal of control not to burst out with laugher during the shoot. Best to all.

---

April 23, 2010 07:18 AM

Shawn Furman said:

I can't wait to see The Third Rule tonight. Aundre Johnson and the cast really seem like they've put a great film together. It's going to be hilarious.

---

April 23, 2010 07:21 AM

Colin Heaney said:

All I keep hearing about is the performance of Fabian Hogarth. I can't wait to check this movie out. Aundre Johnson's past films have been great, and this one looks to be the best of them all.

---

April 23, 2010 09:12 AM

Audrey said:

This movie looks so funny, I absolutely cannot wait to see it! Aundre Johnson is a genius!

---

April 23, 2010 11:11 AM

Brian Schank said:

I just realized that Joel Moore is the same guy from Avatar and Grandma's Boy. This guy is great. Can't wait to see this film.

---

April 23, 2010 08:19 PM

David said:

Not funny.

---

April 23, 2010 09:22 PM

Chris Love said:

Premiere
Just got out of the premiere! Simply fantastic film. Loved every minute of it! Fabian Hogarth was hysterical, Jason Biggs is finally funny again and Joel Moore helped create a trifecta of hilarity. All in all great film and I'm thrilled I got to see it. Aundre you have a golden idol of a film here!! Congrats!!!

---

April 23, 2010 10:17 PM

ML said:

The Third Rule
Remember the Mongoose!! The screening tonight was hilarious. It was so refreshing to have The Third Rule placed in the middle of the other shorts to break up the drama. It was great to have laughs to lighten the mood. Aundre Johnson did a great job and Fabian Hogarth was just great. Can't wait to see it again.

---

April 23, 2010 10:19 PM

J Roman said:

First Screening
I just left the first screening of The Third Rule. Aundre Johnson did a really great job with this film. Having the acting quality mixed in with his great script was really fun to watch. Fabian Hogarth was really funny, and so were Jason Biggs and Joel Moore. In a night full of dramatic shorts, this comedy really was the peak of the night. Tootlepip!!!

---

April 23, 2010 10:24 PM

Mike Vitale said:

I thought I had tickets to a screening of a feature tonight, and I actually had tickets to the short films. I'm actually really happy I did because The Third Rule was great. It was really funny and had some great actors in it. Aundre Johnson was the director. If you get a chance to go to the shorts over the next week of the festival, trust me, see the block that this one is in. It was great.

---

April 23, 2010 11:22 PM

FD said:

Did anyone watch the same shorts? Jason biggs is NOT funny again and Fabian Hogarth rambled on and on. Weak premise, weaker pay-off. Could have been cut in half length wise.

---

April 23, 2010 11:51 PM

Don Matteo said:

3rd rule
Hahahaha! The Third Rule is really funny - and has a great playful spirit about it. I hope these talented guys go on to make a feature of this. Well done all!

---

April 24, 2010 12:00 AM

Ryan Travers said:

Third Rule
This movie was great. Funny concept, funny characters, funny everything. It was really a good movie that I could relate to. In a night full of dramatic shorts, this one really made everyone laugh and remember how much fun movies are. Great job Aundre, cast and crew.

---

April 24, 2010 12:02 AM

Sarah M said:

Fabian
Fabian Hogarth was hilarious. If you actually listen to what he is saying and pay attention, he is hysterical. I had a great time tonight and hope that I can get another ticket to another screening of this short. REMEMBER THE MONGOOSE!

---

April 24, 2010 12:06 AM

Jay Mather said:

Watched the third rule tonight. I'm assuming it was supposed to be funny but it was neither good nor bad---just flat. Weak story no chemistry between Jason Biggs or Joel Moore Fabian Hogarth is a great actor but this just felt forced. Dialogue felt like BAD improv.

---

April 24, 2010 12:10 AM

M Quigley said:

Thanks to Aundre Johnson and the cast and crew of The Third Rule for making such a great short. The writing was funny, the acting was funny, and the Q & A after the screening was funny. Great night all around. Great job!

---

April 24, 2010 12:14 AM

Anonymous said:

Sucks

---

April 24, 2010 12:44 AM

Phil Daly said:

Tonight's Screening
I was at the screening tonight and I just have a couple questions. David, if the time stamp on your message is at 8:19pm, how is it that you thought it was not funny before the film was viewed at 9:30pm?? Interesting how you could find something that you've never seen "not funny". FD, Jay Mather, and Anonymous- if you were really at the screening tonight and saw the film, tell me which directors were present for the Q&A after the screenings. I was in that audience tonight and everyone seemed to love all of these films, so I have a feeling you weren't even in the screening and don't have any idea what you're talking about.

---

April 24, 2010 02:32 PM

JO said:

Great great film, great new direction
Very glad to see the latest, and greatest, version of this film. I fully support Aundre in this cut- I am a 3rd party person with no affiliation between Aundre, cast or crew and I had several harsh thoughts on an earlier cut that had nothing to do with the story or the direction. Good directors and good story tellers do not let weak performers ruin their films. Bravo and I hope you take home gold!

---

April 24, 2010 03:28 PM

bqs4re said:

The Third Rule "Shines" big time!
Nicely done Aundre! Very, Very Funny. Great cast, nice car, VERY nice ladies... In my opinion, this is one of the best, if not "the best" comedy shorts playing at Tribeca. I really hope it gets top honors, and is received well by other directors, film studios and distribution companies. The more you watch this film, the funnier it gets. Jason & Joel work great together, well timed comedy. Were they even following a script?... And who can forget Fabian? That "mongoose man" is an awesome actor, I hope he really "makes it" in this biz! Only one con in my book: Joel really does need a mustache to be driving that sweet Ferrari! :)

---

April 24, 2010 05:02 PM

Debra Dusay said:

The Third Rule--Original and unexpected
Congratulations on "The Third Rule" ! Its fun, original, and a little unexpected absurdity. Love it. Break a leg at Tribeca.

---

April 24, 2010 05:44 PM

Jane Bartelme said:

The Third Rule
Aundre Johnson is the film maker we've been waiting for. The Third Rule surprises and fascinates! Bravo!

---

April 24, 2010 07:16 PM

landerson1116 said:

The Third Rule
Aundre congradulations on "The Third Rule" I loved it, hope for a feature to come out it. Loved the actors everyone was great. Break a leg.

---

April 26, 2010 01:31 PM

www.taurad.com said:

nice!
congrats on getting your film accepted!

---

April 27, 2010 07:59 AM

Ryan Travers said:

Last Nights Screening
Last night I got a chance to go see Between The Lines, which featured The Third Rule. If you have extra time this week to go see a screening of something, go see this. All of the films in this block were great, but The Third Rule was hilarious. Aundre Johnson did a great job on this film and Fabian Hogarth was absolutely brilliant. Great job!

---

April 27, 2010 08:16 AM

JD212 said:

virtual screening
Have been watching thru virtual screening(which is cool) and have been reading all of the comments. So, it's funny to me that the people who are for The Third Rule are anointing this the second coming of film and the people who are against it think it's trash. I, for one, think it's neither great nor terrible. I applaud anyone who gets their film accepted. On the other hand, everyone has an opinion, good and bad, and this is a comment page.....anyone has the right to make a comment whether people like it or not.

---

April 27, 2010 10:16 PM

californiadon said:

Third Rule....
Personaly saw the outtakes / footage from the earlier "Third Rule" project and must say the "slacker" actors sucked (to use such a lame word - but appropriate). Sadly the background story is that in the middle of shooting it, they tried to manipulate the director / creator for "creative control" / ownership and mostly to get a "SAG card". What a lame way of being a "team player". Luckily this project has better actors to carry the vision of this film.

---

April 28, 2010 07:40 PM

cinephilitic said:

Amazed
Personally, it blows my mind that so many people have commented on a film, a short for that matter, that is neither engaging nor funny; and must suck for everyone involved that the comment page has become a sounding board for every disgruntled person on the film. Obviously the director screwed the "original cast" to get Sir Anthony on board and the cast tried to screw the director right back. I wasn't on the set, but by what was being said I doubt I'm far off. What really sucks is the person who wrote the original piece is left out of the shuffle. And this will go down as another bloated short film.

---

April 28, 2010 11:41 PM

James Barnes said:

Even More Amazed
I love how you have such a problem with a comment page being a sounding board for disgruntled people that you just have to make comments for yourself. I'd personally love to know you you claim is the person who wrote this original piece, because I for one know the writer and would love to see if you know anyone of what you are talking about.

---

April 29, 2010 12:03 AM

californiadon said:

You may be right......
The big question will always be; Was the original project a better "quality piece" and a better project than the wonderful project that was entered into the festival. Cinephilitic, Have you ever heard of a recasting of actors. Be it as simple as just firing an actor for insubordination or recast because they chose to try and hijack a project or not listen to the director / creative person on the project. All too often small minded wanna be actors (albeit without SAG cards or talent) are casted for shorts and feature length films. Sometimes those projects are completed and left on a shelf gaining dust bunnies by the minute usually due to having lower tier or a non-existant level of talent. Ever so often a project is recast and has a modicum of success. (perfect example was the Marvel Fantastic Four which was originally shot in 1994 only to keep the rights to the project by the great producer Roger Corman). Several people have posted a few things about this project and the director, with whom I have had great personal experiences and financially have supported his earlier film shorts. It does seem to me that what we have are few disgruntled "wannabe" actors and/or "film critics" who have not seen this film, let alone attended a screening here at Tribeca and are making statements from their homes and keeping their "anonymity". The film should be judged on its merits and by those who have taken the time and resources to see this film and not the words from these numerous posts.

---

May 23, 2010 12:20 AM

Anonymous said:

eat it